Press "Enter" to skip to content

An open letter on intersectionality from Access and DRC

To the students of Vassar College and the community at large,

For the executive boards of Access and the Disability Rights Coalition, intersectionality is more than a buzzword. It is a core tenet of our philosophy: every individual is a culmination of various intersecting identities, and it is our responsibility as activists to defend each and every element of a person. So long as any person suffers from discrimination, violence, or bigotry, regardless of the reason, every disabled person’s freedom and human dignity is threatened. Fighting ableism also requires fighting institutional racism, sexism, Islamophobia, anti-semitism, homophobia, transmisogyny, and any other form of bigotry that holds back progress. That is the basis of intersectionality, and that is the basis of our movement.

In the past few weeks, the United States has been hit with tragedy after tragedy. In Kentucky, a white nationalist murdered Maurice Stallard and Vickie Lee Jones in a targeted racist act against African-Americans. In Pittsburgh, a nazi-sympathizer fired upon Jewish congregants in the Tree of Life Synagogue, killing 11 individuals: Joyce Feinberg, Richard Gottfried, Rose Mallinger, Jerry Rabinowitz, Cecil Rosenthal, David Rosenthal, Bernice Simon, Sylvan Simon, Daniel Stein, Melvin Wax, and Irving Younger. In an interview with Axios, the President of the United States announced his intention to end birthright citizenship, in flagrant violation of the United States Constitution and, more importantly, basic human decency. Access and the Disability Rights Coalition strongly condemn the attacks in Kentucky and Pittsburgh, and the possible revocation of birthright citizenship. They are antithetical to everything that Access, the Disability Rights Coalition, and Vassar College values.

In 2017, when a coalition of neo-nazis, white nationalists, and other staples of the far-right marched on Charlottesville, they chanted that “The Jews will not replace us.” They had bought into a conspiracy theory that “zionist occupied governments” were importing muslims and black people to breed with white women and overtake the caucasian majority in Europe and the United States. This motivated the gunman in Pittsburgh, who admitted that his act was a strike against the Hebrew Immigrant Aid Society. Anti-semitism is a racial issue, tied closely to anti-immigrant sentiment, anti-black racism, and Islamophobia.

Anti-semitism, xenophobia, racism, sexism, and the rise of fascism are Access and DRC’s issues, and the struggle of Jews, women, POC, and the LGBTQ+ community is our struggle. This is not only because of the ableist violence of fascist regimes, but because members of our community are affected by the violence that arises from white supremacy through various intersecting identities. If any disabled person is suffering, we are all suffering.

White supremacy is inherently evil, and all of its supporters must be opposed by whatever means necessary. This is not a controversial position, but it is a difficult one to enforce. It is easy to condemn evil in the abstract, but often not so easy when it is personal. Confronting those in our own lives who benefit from or reinforce systems of oppression is difficult, but necessary if these system will ever be overturned. It can be uncomfortable to confront friends and family, people we care for, about their own bigotry. But it’s necessary to do so. We must condemn the shooter who killed 11 people in a synagogue, but we must also confront our friends who excuse anti-semites and holocaust deniers like Louis Farrakhan, David Irving, or Mahmoud Abbas. We must condemn the police officer who killed an innocent black man or woman because of the color of the skin, but we must also confront our family members who think that African-Americans are lazy or that they should “get over slavery already.” We must condemn the parent who murders their autistic child, but we must also confront our work colleague who excuses it. We must condemn Donald Trump’s sexual violence, but we must also come to terms with abusers in our own life. It is not enough to oppose white supremacist patriarchy in theory; we must apply it in practice.

We must rise up. We must resist. We must revolt, however we can, in ways both small and large. We must remain vigilant and energized. Above all, we must confront hatred without fear without remorse not necessarily because it affects us personally, but because it’s right.

Access and the Disability Rights Coalition are ready to take on this challenge alongside you. For years, our membership has watched in horror as hatred and extremism has remained in the mainstream. While we are shocked by the events in Pittsburgh and Kentucky, these are not isolated incidents. This is a culmination of many years of American politics and rhetoric. This political language has come with terrible costs: fear, indignity, the violation of our most basic human rights, political violence, religious violence, loss of life, and domestic terrorism. This cannot continue.

Despite the costs, we are not hopeless, and we are not giving up. We are ready.

This is our call to action. The battle against white supremacy has just begun, and we intend to do our part. We stand with every disabled person, every person of color, every immigrant, every Jew, every Muslim, every woman, every survivor of sexual or domestic violence, and every individual that is afraid of their own country. We will join you in this fight, because it is our fight too.

And to those who stand in the way of progress, to neo-nazis, to reactionaries, to Brett Kavanaugh, to Donald Trump, to Lindsey Graham, to Richard Spencer, to the Klu Klux Klan, to the Creativity Movement, to Jared Taylor, to David Irving, to Louis Farrakhan, to every person who stands behind a hateful ideology of white supremacy and anti-semitism and white nationalism and patriarchy: your days are numbered. We are the future of America. We will outlive you. We will outlast you. And we will replace you.

Signed,

Access and DRC Executive Boards

Carina Cohen, DRC President

Jesser Horowitz, Co-President of Access

Eric Parlin, Co-President of Access

Sarah Garijo-Garde, DRC Vice President

Chris McCann, Co-Vice President of Access

Lauranne Wolfe, Co-Vice President of Access

Nora Culik, DRC Treasurer

Gabrielle Ho, Treasurer of Access

Clara Layzer, DRC Secretary

Bronwyn Pappas-Byers, Secretary of Access

Nicole Stern, Freshman Representative of Access


Learn more

USA Today – One year after Charlottesville, Trump has normalized racism in America

The New York Times – The Nazi’s First Victims Were the Disabled

The Guardian – The left must restore the ties between antisemitism and other racism

 

One Comment

  1. John Doe November 13, 2018

    “White supremacy is inherently evil, and all of its supporters must be opposed by whatever means necessary. This is not a controversial position, but it is a difficult one to enforce.”

    White supremacy is evil, but not inherently. I’d assert that there is no such thing as a universalizable moral position. Morality is grounded in the realities of societies and social identities. In our democracy, white supremacy is evil because our populace is racially diverse, and white supremacy hopes to silence and disempower people who are meant to be able to self-govern by our society’s constitution. White supremacy is evil because it is tyrannical, not for any “inherent” reason.

    And even if you’re not persuaded, I’ll admit that the ability to self-govern may be a universalizable moral good. But in an imaginary world where everyone is white, white supremacy and self-government would not be mutually exclusive. The reality we face, however, is going to be diverse no matter what, so it’s not true in our world that white supremacy and self-government could coexist. Still, I think that it’s politically problematic to pretend that any grounded moralities can be universalizable, and I’d be happy to engage this point if anyone disagrees or wants me to explain.

    Furthermore, it is, in fact, a controversial position to say that “all of its supporters must be opposed by whatever means necessary.” A diversity of speech and opinion is important in order to sustain our democracy on both a principled and practical level. Who is going to get the job of deciding what is white supremacy and what is not? How would you make those decisions? By what I’ve seen, many people would be happy to disenfranchize half the nation “because they voted for some Trump, so they must be white supremacists.” There is such a high risk of disempowering voices that need to be heard that this statement is by no means largely accepted. Worse, I think this statement, although its sentiment is laudable (Who doesn’t hate supremacists?), is very dangerous on a political and moral level, for it risks disempowering people in the same way white supremacists hope to do so. This statement risks calling for tyranny. We can oppose ideologies, but we don’t have to do it by “any means necessary.”

    It shouldn’t matter to anyone, but I am Jewish and think that the synagogue shooter was evil, and that anyone calling for actual violence should be dealt with by any means necessary, but white supremacy and actual violence, like shooting at innocent people, are not necessarily going to always exist at the same time. If you want people to feel like they are politically empowered and don’t have to use violence in order to be heard (whether they are on the left of the right), engage them, talk to them, especially if you disagree. But keep talking with them, even if you think they won’t listen to you. Most importantly, let them try to persuade you; don’t just tell them they’re wrong. They might be completely wrong, but if they can be persuaded of to run to something so extreme, they can be persuaded to turn around. If people feel like they are being heard, they will focus on speaking better and on better arguments rather than just on “any means necessary.” Don’t just immediately shut them out. Political engagement is the only way we can stop these evils.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *